NFLish Debate #36: Who wins Heisman, does it affect who goes @ #1?

[Cory]

Go

[Justin]

Jameis Winston hands down.  It's not even a contest.

[Cory]

It think its a two horse race between Winston and Manziel, Manziel has better stats by Winston has a better record, but I dont think it'll affect who goes #1.

When Clowney does the combine, he'll be impossible to pass-up for the Texans if they finish last, as I do believe theyll go the Shanahan Cutler route.

I think regardless of his failure to live up to the hype, Clowney will post numbers at the combine that will be truly terrifying. He'll run a 4.4 forty and get at least 30 on the BP, and probably shatter DL shuttle records. Clowney and Watt will be as terrifying as Reggie White and Jerome Brown were in the 90s.

[Jon]

Winston wins and no, it won't effect who goes #1 since he won't be eligible in the 2014 draft.

I think if the Texans finish the season as the worst team, they select a QB, unless they pick one up in free agency or via trade (Big Ben).

 

[Justin]

Winston wins and no, it won't effect who goes #1 since he won't be eligible in the 2014 draft.

I think if the Texans finish the season as the worst team, they select a QB, unless they pick one up in free agency or via trade (Big Ben).

I think the tandem of Watt and Clowney will be too much to pass on.  Bridgewater is good, but his body mimicks that of RGIII and is proned to take some shots.  I wouldn't be my franchise on him.

[Cory]

Derrick Carr has the tools to probably be the most adaptive rookie QB, and he might slip I think.

[The TeeJ of Philly]

I think the tandem of Watt and Clowney will be too much to pass on.  Bridgewater is good, but his body mimicks that of RGIII and is proned to take some shots.  I wouldn't be my franchise on him.

I've watched a good bit of Teddy this year and while he's body looks like RG3, his playstyle is quite the opposite. He has the ability to run for a first if needed, but prefers to stay in the pocket and look for the open receiver.

Its Famous Jamies and not even close. I see Tre Mason jumping into the draft and some team taking him a round or two before he should go. There is no such thing as a first round RB any more.

[Justin]

I've watched a good bit of Teddy this year and while he's body looks like RG3, his playstyle is quite the opposite. He has the ability to run for a first if needed, but prefers to stay in the pocket and look for the open receiver.

Its Famous Jamies and not even close. I see Tre Mason jumping into the draft and some team taking him a round or two before he should go. There is no such thing as a first round RB any more.

Agreed about Bridgewater's style, but I still don't think he's worth burdening his shoulders with the next five years of your franchise.

[The TeeJ of Philly]

Really Houston wouldn't be a bad spot. They're the team that everything went wrong on.

[Justin]

Houston will be back near the top next season.  This is just one of those seasons where for some reason, everything goes down the crapper. They will be back to form next season.

[Cory]

same with Atlanta