NFL Debate #72: Comeback Player of the Year

[Cory]

Just doing these two awards, as Offensive Player is too close to MVP, Defensive MVP is Watt and Coach is Arians are both locks. So have at er

[Cory]

Gronk and Maclin are my two favorites here...but Gronk has the SLIGHTLY better stats, plus his performances led his team to the playoffs unlike Maclin.....

[Doug E Fresh]

Gronk and Maclin are my two favorites here...but Gronk has the SLIGHTLY better stats, plus his performances led his team to the playoffs unlike Maclin.....

Maclin is playing a position where some rookies this year are playing at his level or better.

Gronk is dominating a position where even the other "elites" aren't close.

Gronk without a question.

[Doug E Fresh]

All that being said, Gronk did play a little last year. Maclin didn't see time. Depending on the criteria of the award, could be Maclins.

[The TeeJ of Philly]

I say McClain, the guy was out of football last year. And is the only player on that cowboys defense worth anything this year

[Mike Powers]

I say McClain, the guy was out of football last year. And is the only player on that cowboys defense worth anything this year

Somebody call me?