Just watched it, and may I say- I never thought Tim Burton could direct such a beautiful film! I've always been a fan of burtons art work, but always felt he was the kind of director who could paint the perfect portrait, but failed to tell the story behind it.
This was, in my opinion, his masterpiece.
Absolutely loved it!
Yes it was a very good film, and proof that he can do a great film without Depp in the lead.
For something so ridiculously far fetched it was incredibly real.
Probably in my top ten.