G.M.C.O.A.T Round 4: Red vs The Joker

[Gary]

Red

Movie: Shawshank Redemption

Quote - "My friend Andy Dufrese"

vs



The Joker

Movie: THe Dark Knight

Quote - "Why so serious?"

[Doug E Fresh]

Joker

[GM Franchise]

Joker

[Kieran King]

Red should have never beaten Anton Chigurh, let alone Han freaking Solo. The fact that he's this far through while Alex DeLarge never made it past the qualifiers makes me pretty certain I hate you all.

The Joker, easily.

[Kirk]

Joker. Joker is a bigger character and us essential to his film. I can't really see how Red is different to any other Morgan Freeman character.

[Gary]

I havent comment in these but my take. Without The Joker, Dark Knight would've been meh. He stole every seen he was in and when he wasnt on screen you were dying to see what he did next.

[Ian "Wolfie" Trumps]

I now conceed...the death of Red after fighting his little corner for a lot of this tournament.

[Marq]

Going with Joker, 'cause Red (as Lemke pointed out) was a plot device -- nothing more.